Page 10 of 13
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 5th, 2012, 3:30 pm
by gardengirl
ouellette-k wrote:wow im very sorry to the people ive upset and i can see why some call me creepy. I hate the daily grind feeling like a scumbag going through filthy trash but what options do i have. Even if i could find a minimum wage job i cant keep them due to being antisocial and waking up everyday feeling worthless.Im taking what you throw away and buying food and paying rent.People shouldnt have to work for a home only to look out there window to see a degenerate rifling through there personal trash.Im collecting cans I wouldnt know what to do with credit info if thats what u think and y would i pick cans if i wanted to do criminal acts.Thank you to all who have givin me bags or even a wave,and to those who storm outta there house simply put a sign sayin no cans.Calling the police will only waste tax dollars to give me a fine that i may pay years down the road if i ever get myself together
So you apparently know that it is indeed against the law.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 5th, 2012, 3:49 pm
by Catz
ouellette-k wrote:wow im very sorry to the people ive upset and i can see why some call me creepy. I hate the daily grind feeling like a scumbag going through filthy trash but what options do i have. Even if i could find a minimum wage job i cant keep them due to being antisocial and waking up everyday feeling worthless.Im taking what you throw away and buying food and paying rent.People shouldnt have to work for a home only to look out there window to see a degenerate rifling through there personal trash.Im collecting cans I wouldnt know what to do with credit info if thats what u think and y would i pick cans if i wanted to do criminal acts.Thank you to all who have givin me bags or even a wave,and to those who storm outta there house simply put a sign sayin no cans.Calling the police will only waste tax dollars to give me a fine that i may pay years down the road if i ever get myself together
Why do you drive like a mad man on my street where young kids are?
Why do you leave garbage after?
Why do you drive away when I come to talk to you?
I have no issues giving bottles...just not the way you do it.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 6th, 2012, 7:32 pm
by kumazatheef
gardengirl wrote:So you apparently know that it is indeed against the law.
Which law??
http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/arti ... ourt-rules"Until the garbage is placed at or within reach of the lot line, the householder retains an element of control over its disposition and cannot be said to have unequivocally abandoned it, particularly if it is placed on a porch or in a garage or within the immediate vicinity of the dwelling," he wrote.
Granted, this article/situation primarily concerns itself with RCMP law enforcement for warrants, the wording of the verdict alludes to possible civil implications:
he abandoned his privacy interest when he placed his garbage for collection at the rear of his property where it was accessible to any passing member of the public. P did everything required to rid himself of the items taken as evidence. His conduct was incompatible with any reasonable expectation of confidentiality.
http://www.canlii.org/en/ca/scc/doc/200 ... scc17.htmlAs for the accusations of bad driving, well, that's all under MVA and not part of the original post.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 6th, 2012, 7:54 pm
by gardengirl
The fact that his driving was not in the original post does not change the fact that he is driving illegally.
I and others here have witnessed it.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 7th, 2012, 9:38 am
by theyeti
It's a discussion forum/do not post just emoticons/Trip
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 7th, 2012, 1:19 pm
by not so new to town
we all know its not against the law, and if its garbage , and you put out it there. what do you care if hes going through it anyway? your not the one looking or going through it, so who cares. maybe he has kids. Or just needs to eat and pay bills. better then sitting on welfare. and i am not sure who posted it, but if it is such a concern put a seperate bag out beside it, then he wont rumage through the bin, better yet. Tape a sign to the lid expressing there is no cans in the bin.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 7th, 2012, 1:46 pm
by Fancy
It's against the bylaw which was posted earlier.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 7th, 2012, 1:49 pm
by theyeti
call the police when u see him . tell them a really really really really scary man is picking thru your garbage taking bottles .. im sure the swat team will show up in a few seconds with such a disturbing complaint
i mean who wouldnt fee threatened by a bottle picker they r scary
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 7th, 2012, 2:09 pm
by Catz
Why does he not answer my questions?
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 8th, 2012, 10:31 am
by OnTheRoadAgain
It isn't supposed to, but it does and as long as it does people will look for it and take it for the coin.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 8th, 2012, 10:36 am
by OnTheRoadAgain
Fancy wrote:It's against the bylaw which was posted earlier.
which is complaint driven and not otherwise enforced.
Also, supreme court laws supercede bylaws.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 8th, 2012, 11:00 am
by OnTheRoadAgain
Catz wrote:Why does he not answer my questions?
It may not even be 'him'.
"He" may be another bottle picker who can relate.
"He" may have never been on your street.
"He" may not even own a car.
and "He" might also be a 'she'.
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 8th, 2012, 11:30 am
by Fancy
OnTheRoadAgain wrote:Fancy wrote:It's against the bylaw which was posted earlier.
which is complaint driven and not otherwise enforced.
Also, supreme court laws supercede bylaws.
Where in the supreme court rules does it state it's okay to garbage pick?
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 8th, 2012, 11:36 am
by theyeti
lol supreme court .. garbage picking all in one post !
Re: Is this against the law?
Posted: Nov 8th, 2012, 11:39 am
by Catz
ouellette-k wrote:wow im very sorry to the people ive upset and i can see why some call me creepy. I hate the daily grind feeling like a scumbag going through filthy trash but what options do i have. Even if i could find a minimum wage job i cant keep them due to being antisocial and waking up everyday feeling worthless.Im taking what you throw away and buying food and paying rent.People shouldnt have to work for a home only to look out there window to see a degenerate rifling through there personal trash.Im collecting cans I wouldnt know what to do with credit info if thats what u think and y would i pick cans if i wanted to do criminal acts.Thank you to all who have givin me bags or even a wave,and to those who storm outta there house simply put a sign sayin no cans.Calling the police will only waste tax dollars to give me a fine that i may pay years down the road if i ever get myself together
Does this answer your question road boy?